Starbucks grilled cheese recipe: best Starbucks sandwich recipe, tips, step-by-step guide

True to its word, Starbucks makes one of the top grilled cheeses. What is their method? It’s just cheese that’s fried, right? What is Starbucks’ trade secret?

While I love all Starbucks hot sandwiches, I’m not prepared to pay a few dollars (plus tax!) for something I can easily make at home.

starbucks grilled cheese featured

Everyone who has tried my Starbucks Crispy Grilled Cheese Imitation Recipe has already given it rave reviews! Sincerely, in my humble opinion and that of my family, better than Starbucks. The Parmesan crust is brilliant since it makes the bread incredibly crunchy and light-flavored. It all takes around five minutes, which is less time than I spend on the road!

This cheese can also be grilled in a deep fryer! It’s ideal — quick, and easy, and your kitchen stays tidy!

Table of Contents

A Starbucks Grilled Cheese Sandwich: What Is It? What makes a grilled cheese sandwich great?

For a long time I could not understand why my friends are crazy about this dish. After a while, I was able to experience this divine taste of Starbucks fried cheese for myself. And I can say that it was unsurpassed.

Naturally, I wanted to understand how Starbucks makes grilled cheese so that I could replicate this dish at home.

If you pay attention to the Starbucks website, you can see that the sandwich is described as “a mixture of white cheddar cheese and mozzarella cheese on sourdough toast with Parmesan butter.” In addition, the list of products used includes dried garlic.

Well, that’s where I started until I was able to make an incredible Starbucks-style fried cheese sandwich!

starbucks grilled cheese 8

Other copycat recipes: Starbucks Irish cream cold brew– incredibly delicious drink. You can cook it at home.

WHAT WILL ATTRACT YOU TO THIS RECIPE Starbucks grilled cheese copycat

If you’ve ever eaten Starbucks grilled cheese sandwiches, you already know how amazing they are. Having tried them at least once, you are unlikely to want to do them differently.

But why not make it yourself? After all, for its preparation there is no need for sophisticated equipment or hard-to-get products. The recipe is very simple! It will be a sandwich with the same taste as the one you can find in a coffee shop.

There is no Starbucks in my area. Therefore, earlier my husband and children and I had to spend a lot of time on the road to the coffee shop. This sandwich costs over $6, so it’s quite an expensive habit to start with.

You can do it ANYTIME without running to Starbucks because it’s so easy!

Starbucks grilled cheese sandwich: recipe ingredients

The following materials are required to produce this delectable Starbucks knockoff grilled cheese sandwich:

  • 2 tablespoons melted butter;
  • 2 teaspoons grated parmesan cheese
  • Ground garlic
ingredients needed to make starbucks grilled cheese 1024x683 1

Four slices of sourdough bread, two slices each of mozzarella cheese and white cheddar cheese.

COMMENTS ABOUT INGREDIENTS for Starbucks grilled cheese sandwich

When more than one sort of cheese is used, grilled cheese sandwiches are always better and more difficult to make. Utilize at least one mildly fatty cheese that melts smoothly. Fontina, Provolone, Havarti, American, Monterey Jack, Colby, and Gouda are some of the most popular processed cheeses.

For a deeper flavor, include still another type of cheese. Swiss and yellow Cheddar are both good possibilities.

You don’t have to spend a lot of money on cheese because even inexpensive deli slices melt and taste great.

  • Cheese: For its grilled cheese sandwiches, Starbucks combines mozzarella and white cheddar cheese. Because I believe it makes the SOFTEST grilled cheese, I prefer SLICE cheese. However, grated cheese also works. I purchase American White Cheddar cheese at the deli counter at my neighborhood supermarket chain. Other cheeses that melt and function well include provolone, havarti, fontina, and yellow cheddar.
  • Bread: The closest thing to what Starbucks uses is a plain loaf of sourdough bread, like this one from San Francisco.

Starbucks grilled cheese sandwich: PASTE BY PASTE

Here are some brief guidelines in pictures. Below I will also present a more detailed step-by-step instruction, although I am sure that even now everything will be clear to you.

how to make starbucks grilled cheese step by step 1
  • Combine butter and parmesan cheese in a small mixing bowl.
  • Generously spread the butter mixture on the bread.
  • Spread some cheese on the bread’s unbuttered side.
  • Fry for 1 to 2 minutes on each side in a pan. Slice in half, then serve right away.

Starbucks grilled cheese recipe: A STEP-BY-STEP GUIDE

photo 1528736235302 52922df5c122 1.04.16 PM

If you’re committed to the Starbucks Grilled Cheese Sandwich, this Starbucks Grilled Cheese Imitation Recipe is a must-try. It’s incredibly easy to make at home using a combination of white cheddar, mozzarella and parmesan garlic butter.

  • Mix butter and parmesan cheese in a small bowl. You will get pasta with parmesan.
  • Brush generously with the butter mixture on one side of each slice of bread.
  • Arrange the mozzarella and cheddar cheese slices on the bread. But you need to do this on the side that is not smeared with oil! For frying, a large frying pan is suitable, which we must heat to low or medium temperature. Add sandwiches and cook 1-2 minutes per side or until cheese is melted. To melt the cheese, make sure the fire is kept at a sufficient level. Tip: To make the cheese melt faster, cover the pan with a lid!
  • And voila! Take the fried cheese out of the pan, cut it in half and you can immediately enjoy the incredible taste, viscous cheese, crispy crust … Mmmm. I’m already salivating!
Starbucks grilled cheese

Can I air fryer best grilled cheese sandwiches?

Definitely. The environment is unchanged. You will air fry for a few minutes on each side at 400 degrees. Watch your bread carefully, and flip it when it is golden brown.

Starbucks grilled cheese copycat: RECIPE GUIDELINES

To ensure that the cheese melts and the sandwich doesn’t brown too much, keep the heat in the skillet at LOW to MEDIUM-LOW.

To help the cheese melt, place a baking sheet over the pan for about a minute.

Here are some pointers and techniques for creating a flawless grilled cheese sandwich every time at Starbucks.

  • Selection of cheese. Apply pre-grated cheese. We advise shredding your own cheese if you intend to utilize grated cheese.
  • How to achieve ooey-gooey. This will help avoid the anti-caking chemical that is included with the pre-shredded cheese. We prefer to utilize cheese slices while producing cheese for the finest results. Make your cheese relatively thin if you cut it yourself so that it will melt relatively quickly.
  • Cheddar melting technique. Keep the temperature at medium and cover the sandwich with a little lid if the cheese is having difficulties melting. After a few minutes, flip the sandwich over and wait until the cheese is melted.
l intro 1618503297

In Starbucks Grilled Cheese, is shredded cheese allowed?

Sliced cheese melts more evenly than grated cheese, but if you only have shredded cheddar and mozzarella, you can still use that. Just make sure to layer it evenly and let it melt through the centre.


Even though it’s ideal to eat this sandwich right once, you CAN store leftovers! For up to two days, keep in the refrigerator in an airtight bag or air-tight container.

The greatest way to warm up is with a toaster! The sandwich is lowered for a few minutes. Alternatively, heat in a skillet.


Although provolone, havarti, fontina, and yellow cheddar cheese melt nicely and work well, Starbucks utilizes a blend of mozzarella and white cheddar cheese.

IMG 5324

The grilled cheese served at Starbucks is made with mozzarella and cheddar cheese. Because I believe it makes the SOFTEST grilled cheese, I prefer SLICE cheese. However, grated cheese also works.

I purchase American Cheddar cheese at the deli counter at my neighborhood supermarket chain. Other cheeses that melt and function well include provolone, Havarti, fontina, and yellow cheddar.

Nutrition Calories perfect starbucks grilled cheese

  • 525 kcal of calories;
  • 972 mg of sodium;
  • 113 mg of potassium;
  • 38 g of carbohydrates;
  • 27 g of protein;
  • 1.5 g of fiber;
  • 1.8 g of sugar;
  • 378 mg of calcium;
  • 30 g of fat;
  • 18 g of saturated fat;
  • 85 mg of cholesterol;
  • 3 mg of iron.


Dairy and wheat ingredients are found in this recipe. Use suitable substitutions for any of these to which you have an allergy.


Which cheese works best in a grilled cheese sandwich?

For the sandwich’s filling, Starbucks combines white cheddar and mozzarella cheese. Butter and Parmesan cheese are combined and placed over the outside.

How to Make Homemade Starbucks Cheese?


A big skillet should be heated to medium. Sandwiches should be added and cooked for 1–2 minutes on each side, or until cheese has melted. To allow the cheese to melt, make sure the heat is kept at a low to medium level. Pro tip: To hasten the melting of the cheese, cover the pan with a baking sheet!


Naturally, you may grill this cheese with any type of cheese you choose! Likely, it will have a slightly different flavor from what you would get from Starbucks.
But in all honesty, you’ll be alright as long as you have the garlic parmesan butter!
Here are some more cheeses that can be used:
Colby Jack;
Orange Cheddar;
Parmesan cheese;
Monterey Jack;
Pepper Jack;
I also don’t mind fried brie or blue/gorgonzola cheese, although both will significantly alter the flavor of this sandwich from Starbucks.

IS ANOTHER BREAD PERMITTED for make Starbucks grilled cheese?

You can make this with any kind of bread, but sourdough bread is the best. I urge you to try sourdough bread even if you don’t think you’ll enjoy it.
If you don’t have sourdough bread, I suggest brioche or ciabatta. Also delicious would be multigrain.

Does grilled cheese come with butter or mayonnaise to make Starbucks grilled cheese?

Butter is used in the Starbucks recipe. Of course, you may experiment with various versions if you choose, such as using mayonnaise in place of the butter.

Which is better for perfect grilled cheese: butter or olive oil?

The sandwich is described as “a blend of cheddar cheese and mozzarella on sourdough toast with parmesan butter spread” on Starbucks’ website. On their ingredient list, they also include dehydrated garlic. You can try an olive oil sandwich right now if you want to! Your thoughts should be shared in the comments section later.

What does grilled cheese cost at Starbucks?

DWELL The Ultimate Starbucks Grilled Cheese Copycat Recipe scaled 1

Depending on where you live, prices change. Starbucks grilled cheeses cost $6.25 in my neighborhood, although they may cost somewhat more or less elsewhere. Use the Starbucks app to check the price at your neighborhood location.
It costs a tiny fraction of what it would if you made it yourself. We predict that cooking this at home will cost less than $1 per sandwich, depending on where you purchase your ingredients.

How many calories are in a Grilled Cheese at Starbucks?

Starbucks’ grilled cheese dish has 520 calories.


To spread the cheese butter over the starting, you will need a nice frying pan, a spatula, a small bowl, and a knife.
If you wish to grate your own cheese, which I think gives this recipe more flavor, a Parmesan grater is not necessary.


The greatest time to eat grilled cheese is right after you make it. If you have leftovers, you can keep them in the fridge for up to three days if they are sealed tightly.
Enjoy the sandwich after rewarming it in the microwave or over medium heat for a few minutes on each side.

What about Starbucks grilled cheese?

Yes, Starbucks sells grilled cheese sandwiches, but we think they’re fairly expensive, so we’ll teach you how to make the ideal ripoff recipe for far less money.

Are the sandwiches at Starbucks frozen?

Yes, frozen and reheatable Starbucks sandwiches are shipped. They are not made by the barista at home.

Can I buy Starbucks sandwiches frozen?

Frozen food is available at Starbucks.

How will the Starbucks Grilled Cheese dish seem and taste?

Your flawless grilled cheese will have a golden brown outside and an interior of gooey white cheese. The toasty bread will be covered with butter and toasted parmesan.

An unhealthy grilled cheese sandwich

The healthiness of fried cheese will depend on your dietary constraints. It might not be good for you to eat grilled cheese if you have a wheat or dairy allergy. Or, eating a fried cheese sandwich could be unhealthy if you’re on a low-fat diet and using standard cheese and regular butter.

How can I recreate the Starbucks grilled cheese at home?

Use dry heat, such as in a toaster or standard oven, to reheat Starbucks grilled cheese at home. The sandwich should be heated to 350 degrees Fahrenheit until the cheese begins to melt. A sandwich will get moister when it is microwaved for reheating.

A Starbucks grilled cheese costs how much?

A sandwich with handmade cheese that is grilled is quite affordable. You believe that you must purchase a loaf of bread, yet premium sourdough only costs about $3. Add two kinds of cheese, and for our sandwich, we’ll use a slice of mozzarella and a piece of white cheddar that each cost less than $2.
We currently have around $7. Considering that we anticipate being able to prepare 8 sandwiches with the acquired ingredients, we can then divide this sum by 8. So, based on our calculations, making this sandwich only costs roughly $0.87.


I enjoy making my favorite coffee shop dishes at home, and I have a ton of Starbucks clone recipes waiting for you. All of these are simple to make and have café-ёlike flavors. Try the Irish cream cold brew from Starbucks. It’s not that difficult to create this delicious beverage at home.


This grilled cheese tastes exactly like the one you get at Starbucks and is SO amazing!

When my husband had a bite, he was astounded and overjoyed. He enjoyed his first Starbucks grilled cheese experience with me, but when we got home, he was shocked by the price of the two sandwiches and two coffees.

Do not get me wrong, I still adore getting fried cheese from Starbucks when I need a quick and simple lunch on the road, but now we can also get it whenever we want at home!

The only drawback to this recipe is that you could find yourself wanting to have this cheesy, buttery snack for lunch every day.

But at least you can take pleasure in it in your home comfort! Who’s hungry for lunch right now?

If you enjoy Starbucks sandwich and have tried this copycat Starbucks grilled cheese, please let me know in the comments section below!

Helena Tasty

Leave a Comment